Strategic bombing during World War II

Strategic bombing during World War II
Part of World War II

A B-24 on a bomb run over the Astra Romana refinery in Ploiești, Romania, during Operation Tidal Wave[1]
Location
European Theatre of World War II
Pacific Theatre of World War II
Belligerents
Allied Powers
 United Kingdom
 United States
 Canada
 Australia
 New Zealand
 Soviet Union
 FTR (1939–1940)
 Free France (1940–1944)
 PGFR (1944–1945)
 SPR (1939)
 Poland
 Czechoslovakia
 China
Axis powers
 Germany
 Japan
 Italy
 Hungary
 Romania
 Slovakia
 Bulgaria
 Finland
Commanders and leaders
Charles Portal
Richard Peirse
Arthur Harris
Arthur Tedder
Henry Arnold
Carl Spaatz
Curtis LeMay
Clifford McEwen
George Jones
Alexander Novikov
Sergei Khudyakov
Alexander Golovanov
Hermann Göring
Albert Kesselring
Wolfram von Richthofen
Hugo Sperrle
Naruhiko Higashikuni
Hajime Sugiyama
Masakazu Kawabe
Chūichi Nagumo
Francesco Pricolo
Rino Corso Fougier
Ettore Muti
Kálmán Ternegg
Gheorghe Jienescu
Jarl Lundqvist
Casualties and losses
Total: 749,940–1,305,029 dead
  • 248,664 military dead

Britain:

  • 60,000 civilians killed
  • 160,000 airmen (all Allies, Europe)[2][3]

China:

  • 260,000–351,000 Chinese civilians[4][5]
  • At least 682 aircrew from both the regular air force (RoCAF) and crew members from warlord air forces KIA[6]

France:

  • 67,000 civilians killed from US-UK bombing
  • Half of the 2,500 French crewmen of the British RAF bomber command perished [7]

Netherlands:

  • 1,250–1,350 killed (army and civilians) between 10–15 May 1940
  • 10,000 Dutch civilians killed by air bombings from Allied Forces alone after 15 May 1940

Poland:

  • 50,000 civilians in the 1939 campaign (including artillery bombardment and ground fighting).[8] 2,500 – 7,000 civilians killed by bombing in Warsaw in 1939.[9]
  • 2416 airmen of bombing squadrons (Polish Airforce in the West)[10]

Soviet Union:

  • 51,526 – 500,000 Soviet civilians[a]
  • 2,700 airmen (Japan)[12]

United States:

  • 79,265 airmen/personnel (Europe)
  • Over 3,033 airmen (Japan)[13]

Yugoslavia:

  • 1,500 – 17,000 civilians in Belgrade
Total: 790,509–1,693,374+ dead

Germany:

  • 353,000–635,000 civilians killed, including foreign workers[b]
  • Very heavy damage to infrastructure

Japan:

  • 330,000–500,000 civilians killed[15]
  • 20,000 soldiers killed
    (in Hiroshima)
  • Very heavy damage to industry

Italy:

  • 60,000–100,000 civilians killed[16]
  • 5,000 soldiers killed[16]
  • Heavy damage to industry

Hungary:

  • 19,135–30,000 killed and 25,000 wounded[17][18]
  • Heavy damage to industry[19]

Romania:

  • 7,693 civilians killed and 7,809 wounded
  • Destruction and heavy damage to infrastructure and oil refineries[20]

Bulgaria:

  • 1,374 dead and 1,743 injured[21]
    12,564 buildings damaged, of which 2,670 completely destroyed[21]

Thailand:

  • At least 2,000 dead.[22]

Strategic bombing in World War II was when countries used large groups of airplanes to drop bombs on factories, cities, and transportation systems. The goal was to stop the enemy’s ability or will to fight by damaging its infrastructure and affecting its people.

Background and early use

This kind of bombing started when Germany invaded Poland on 1 September 1939, and its air force attacked Polish towns. As the war grew, both Axis and Allied nations carried out such bombings. Britain responded to German attacks with its own raids on German military bases in March 1940. In September 1940, Germany bombed British cities in what became known as the Blitz.

Allied strategy in Europe

From 1942, British bombing shifted toward industrial and civilian areas. At the same time, the United States joined with the Royal Air Force in what was called the Combined Bomber Offensive (CBO). British bombers usually flew at night, while American planes attacked during the day. In 1943 the CBO focused on destroying Germany’s fighter aircraft production, later targeting V-weapon sites and oil plants.

Daylight U.S. raids used B‑17 and B‑24 bombers with precision devices like the Norden bombsight to target factories and railways. British night attacks used large numbers of Lancasters and Halifaxes to hit entire cities. These huge bomber fleets, often over 1,000 strong, aimed to overwhelm German defences.

Impact on Germany

Major Allied raids on oil refineries, transportation hubs, factories, and cities like Hamburg (Operation Gomorrah, July 1943) caused firestorms and mass damage. Hamburg lost about 60% of its housing and tens of thousands died. Attacks on refineries and transport systems severely hurt Germany’s ability to move supplies and fuel its army. By late 1944, Allied bombers, protected by fighters like the P‑51 Mustang, damaged German military and infrastructure so deeply that Germany's war effort collapsed in early 1945.

Air campaign in the Pacific

In the Pacific, the U.S. initially used B‑29 Superfortress bombers from bases in China, but these were limited in range. After capturing islands like Saipan and Tinian in mid‑1944, B‑29s could reach deeper into Japan. From late 1944, incendiary bombing on Tokyo and other cities created massive firestorms. On March 9–10, 1945, over 330 B‑29s dropped napalm bombs on Tokyo, killing more than 100,000 people and destroying large areas. In August 1945, the U.S. dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki .

Effectiveness and controversy

After the war, the United States conducted the Strategic Bombing Survey. It confirmed that Allied bombing significantly damaged Germany’s oil production and transport systems and helped end the war. However, German aircraft, steel, and tank production even increased during the bombing, making overall effectiveness debatable. Civilian casualties were high—hundreds of thousands to over a million—and millions lost their homes.

Historians and ethicists continue to debate whether the bombing was necessary or moral. Some argue that destroying oil supplies shortened the conflict and saved lives. Others see the bombing of entire cities as an unethical attack on civilians.

Aircraft and defence

Europe’s bombers mainly used B‑17s, B‑24s, British Lancasters and Halifaxes, escorted by long-range P‑51 Mustangs from 1943 onward. In the Pacific, B‑29s flew high-altitude missions, dropping both incendiary and atomic bombs. German defences included fighters and anti-aircraft guns, while Japan’s air defences were too weak to stop the B‑29 raids.

Notes

  1. British historian Richard Overy considers the 500,000 order of magnitude, claimed after the war in Soviet publications, to be "a rhetorical statistic, to demonstrate the level of sacrifice of the Soviet people and the wickedness of the German enemy". The figure "bears no relation to the detailed wartime documentary evidence". A much lower figure (51,526) is borne out by such evidence and "is much more consistent with the nature of the German bombing effort and the declining capability of the German bomber force as it struggled to sustain support for the ground war with dwindling resources",[11]
  2. The 353,000 estimate is from Richard Overy, who explains this figure as follows:[14] "If it is assumed that the figure of 271,000 dead by January 1945 is a realistic, if not precise, total (and there are archive figures which suggest a lower sum), it is possible to extrapolate from the last five months of heavy raiding for which records exist (September 1944 to January 1945) in order to find a possible order of magnitude for deaths in the last three months of the war. The average death toll for these five months was 18,777, which would give an aggregate figure for the whole war period of 328,000, though it would not allow for the exceptional casualty level at Dresden, confirmed by the latest research at approximately 25,000. Adding this would produce a total figure of approximately 353,000, representing 82,000 deaths in the last months. Detailed reconstruction of deaths caused by Royal Air Force bombing from February to May 1945, though incomplete, suggests a total of at least 57,000. If casualties inflicted by the American air forces are assumed to be lower, since their bombing was less clearly aimed at cities, an overall death toll of 82,000 is again statistically realistic. In the absence of unambiguous statistical evidence, the figure of 353,000 gives an approximate scale consistent with the evidence. It is a little over half the figure of 625,000 arrived at in the 1950s."

References

  1. Duga, James; Stewart, Carroll (2002). Ploesti. Brassey's. ISBN 978-1-57488-510-1.
  2. Crook, Paul (2003). "Chapter 10 "The case against Area Bombing"". In Peter Hore (ed.). Patrick Blackett: Sailor, Scientist, and Socialist. Routledge. p. 176. ISBN 978-0-7146-5317-4.
  3. André Corvisier (1994). A Dictionary of Military History and the Art of War, Blackwell Publishing, ISBN 0-631-16848-6. "Germany, air battle (1942–45)" by P. Facon and Stephen J. Harris p. 312
  4. Jennifer M. Lind (2010). "Sorry States: Apologies in International Politics". Cornell University Press. p.28. ISBN 0-8014-7628-3
  5. R.J. Rummel (31 August 2007). China's Bloody Century: Genocide and Mass Murder Since 1900. Transaction Publishers.
  6. 徐 (Xú), 2016, pp. 1-13.
  7. "Memorial to French Bomber Crews".
  8. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, "Poles: Victims of the Nazi Era, 1933 to 1945." Reproduced with permission in A Teacher's Guide to the Holocaust.
  9. Richard Overy, The Bombing War. Europe 1939-1945, Penguin Books, PDF edition, p. 79: "The claims that between 20,000 and 40,000 died is certainly an exaggeration, for fatalities on this scale would have required a firestorm on the scale of Hamburg in 1943 or Dresden in 1945, and of that there is no evidence, nor was the German Air Force at that stage capable of creating one. Current estimates suggest around 7,000 dead, on the assumption that casualty rates per ton of bombs might have equalled the Dresden raid, but a casualty rate equivalent to the Blitz on London would mean around 2,500 deaths on the basis of the limited tonnage dropped."
  10. "Dywizjony bombowe w Polskich Siłach Zbrojnych na Zachodzie". Archived from the original on 2021-10-06. Retrieved 2025-06-13.
  11. Overy The Bombing War. Europe 1939-1945, Penguin Books, PDF edition, p. 228
  12. Kerr (1991), p. 276
  13. Kerr, E. Bartlett (1991). Flames over Tokyo : the U.S. Army Air Force's incendiary campaign against Japan, 1944-1945. Internet Archive. New York : D.I. Fine. p. 276. ISBN 978-1-55611-301-7.
  14. The Bombing War. Europe 1939-1945, Penguin Books, PDF edition, pp. 458-459)
  15. Matthew White Twentieth Century Atlas – Death Tolls: Allies bombing of Japan lists the following totals and sources
    • 330,000: 1945 US Strategic Bombing Survey;
    • 363,000: (not including post-war radiation sickness); John Keegan The Second World War (1989);
    • 374,000: R. J. Rummel, including 337,000 democidal;
    • 435,000: Paul Johnson Modern Times (1983)
    • 500,000: (Harper Collins Atlas of the Second World War)
  16. 16.0 16.1 Marco Gioannini, Giulio Massobrio, Bombardate l'Italia. Storia della guerra di distruzione aerea 1940–1945, p. 491
  17. Pataky, Rozsos & Sárhidai 1993, p. 235.
  18. Ungváry 2004, p. 476.
  19. Pataky, Rozsos & Sárhidai 1993, pp. 229–232.
  20. Zaloga, Steven J. (2019). Ploesti 1943: The great raid on Hitler's Romanian oil refineries. Oxford: Osprey Publishing. p. 90. ISBN 9781472831965.
  21. 21.0 21.1 Kiradzhiev, Svetlin (2006). Sofia 125 Years Capital 1879–2004 Chronicle (in Bulgarian). Sofia: IK Gutenberg. p. 196. ISBN 954-617-011-9.
  22. E. Bruce Reynolds, "Aftermath of Alliance: The Wartime Legacy in Thai-Japanese Relations", Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, v21, n1, March 1990, pp. 66–87.